(Thanks for everyone’s likes and appreciation. If this article resonates with you, please “like” and “recommend”, thank you all!)
Article Overview
When selecting components for industrial control projects, there are many factors to consider, such as equipment reliability and budget. Besides budget, the most troublesome aspect is brand selection. There are numerous touchscreen brands on the market, each claiming to be the best. So, which one should we choose?
Which touchscreen brand is the best to use? Which brand offers the best cost-performance ratio? For seasoned professionals in our field, the most reliable and frequently used tools in their toolbox ultimately boil down to these two brands: Siemens and Weintek.
Why these two?
1. Siemens: The Absolute Leader, the Standard for High-End Projects
First, let’s talk about Siemens. There’s no debate here; for projects with a bit of scale or where the client has a generous budget, it is the first choice.
1. Why choose Siemens?
If you are working on large equipment, production line automation, or projects that require extremely high stability and reliability, the Siemens Comfort Panel and Basic Panel series are almost the only choices. This is not superstition, but the power of the ecosystem.
-
Seamless Ecosystem Collaboration: If your PLC is Siemens S7-1200/1500, you don’t need to hesitate. In the TIA Portal software, from PLC configuration and programming to HMI screen design, all variables can be dragged and dropped with one click, seamlessly integrated. This improvement in development efficiency far exceeds the price difference of the hardware itself. You won’t have to stay up late worrying about communication issues; the software solves everything for you.
-
Stability Above All: In industrial environments, stability is paramount. You might complain that Siemens screens are expensive, but very few people complain about their instability. They can withstand harsh electrical environments without crashing or going black, allowing you to sleep soundly. After the equipment leaves the factory, it is also the part that gives you the most peace of mind.
-
Brand Added Value: When reporting solutions to clients, mentioning a complete Siemens solution naturally instills more trust in the client. This has an intangible benefit for project closure and subsequent payments.
2. When to use it?When the budget is sufficient, the project is important, and the main control is Siemens PLC. For example, for large production lines, critical equipment, or export projects, choosing Siemens with your eyes closed will definitely not be a mistake.
2. Weintek: The King of Cost-Performance, the “Magic Tool” for Small and Medium Projects
If Siemens is the “regular army,” then Weintek is the most flexible “special forces,” used by almost every engineer.
1. Why choose it?
-
Unmatched Compatibility: This is its strongest selling point. If you are working on a Mitsubishi system today, an Omron device tomorrow, and perhaps Delta or Inovance the day after, you cannot prepare a different screen for each brand. One Weintek can work with almost all mainstream PLCs, with an extremely rich driver library, greatly reducing your inventory and learning costs.
-
Extremely High Cost-Performance Ratio: For one-third or even less of the price, you can achieve most of the functions of the basic Siemens models. For cost-sensitive small and medium-sized devices and non-standard automation projects, it is a lifesaver. Being able to reduce project budgets is a core competitive advantage.
-
User-Friendly Software, Abundant Resources: The EBPro software is very quick to learn, with almost no learning curve. More importantly, any strange problem you encounter can almost always be found in forums. A large user base brings a wealth of learning resources and case studies, which is crucial for both beginners and experienced professionals seeking efficiency.
2. When to use it?When the budget is limited, quick delivery is needed, and the PLC brands are mixed. For example, for small and medium-sized devices, R&D test benches, renovation projects, or when the PLC is not Siemens, Weintek is the optimal solution.
3. Selection Principles of Experienced Engineers
After discussing so much, how should we choose? I have summarized a few practical principles:
-
Choose Based on the Situation: If the PLC is Siemens, prioritize Siemens screens; don’t create future troubles just to save a little money. If the PLC is another brand or if the project has mixed PLC brands, go directly with Weintek.
-
Tailor to the Project: For large, high-end projects, reliability is the priority; choose Siemens. For small to medium-sized projects with fierce price competition, cost control is the priority; choose Weintek.
-
Consider Future Maintenance: Once the equipment is sold, how skilled are the client’s maintenance personnel? If they are more familiar with Weintek, using a Siemens screen might actually increase after-sales costs.
In summary:
There is no best brand, only the most suitable choice.
-
Siemens does not just sell screens; it sells a stable and efficient ecosystem.
-
Weintek does not just sell screens; it sells a highly cost-effective universal solution.
Experienced engineers prefer them because we know which tools to use in which scenarios to get the job done most efficiently and reliably. This is the true “insider knowledge.”
1
END
1
Previous Articles
Step-by-step guide on controlling stepper motors with sequence function diagrams and ladder diagrams (including wiring/program diagrams).Say goodbye to programming confusion! Learn every step of sequential control from the automatic shearing machine PLC control, a typical case of Siemens S7-1200 PLC controlling an automatic shearing machine.Practical case: Two S7-1200 PLCs achieving PROFINET communication, with extremely detailed steps and all programs included, just follow the instructions to implement it.Practical case: This is how to control a S7-1200 cyclical color light, with complete source code, and you can replicate it after reading!Essential for advanced electricians: Automatic doors controlled by Siemens S7-1200 PLC.Essential for advanced electricians: Traffic lights at intersections controlled by Siemens S7-1200 PLC.Essential for advanced electricians: Automatic assembly lines controlled by Siemens S7-1200 PLC.Essential for advanced electricians: Automatic mail sorting machines controlled by Siemens S7-1200 PLC.
If you enjoy the articles from Industrial Control Electrician, please click on the business card to follow me! I will continue to share technical insights about PLCs and industrial robots!