Why C or C++ is Better than Python for Embedded Systems

Embedded systems are specialized computing systems designed for specific tasks, often constrained by hardware limitations such as processing power, memory, and real-time requirements. When developing embedded system software, choosing the right programming language is crucial. While Python is widely used for general programming, automation, and scripting, C and C++ remain the mainstream choices for embedded systems.

Key Requirements of Embedded Systems

Before comparing programming languages, it is important to understand the key requirements of embedded systems:

·Low memory footprint: Embedded devices typically have limited RAM and storage space.

·Efficient CPU usage: Embedded systems often have low-power processors with limited clock speeds.

·Real-time processing: Many embedded applications (e.g., automotive and industrial systems) require real-time responses.

·Direct hardware access: Embedded software interacts closely with hardware components such as sensors, actuators, and microcontrollers.

·Portability and optimization: Code must be optimized for performance and power consumption.

Comparison of C, C++, and Python in Embedded Systems

Feature	C	C++	Python
Execution Speed	Fast	Fast	Slow (interpreted language)
Memory Usage	Low	Moderate	High (due to dynamic typing & garbage collection)
Real-Time Capabilities	Yes	Yes	No
Hardware Access	Direct	Direct	Indirect (through libraries)
Power Efficiency	High	High	Low
Portability	High	High	Low (requires Python runtime)
Ease of Development	Moderate	Moderate	Easy
Use in Safety-Critical Systems	Yes	Yes	No

03. Why is C Language Preferred in Embedded Systems?

C is often the default choice for embedded development because:

a. Low-level hardware access

·C provides pointers, bitwise operations, and direct memory manipulation, allowing for efficient interaction with hardware registers.

·Example: Writing to hardware registers using C

#define GPIO_PORT (*(volatile unsigned int*)0x40021000)

GPIO_PORT = 0x01; // Set GPIO pin

b. Real-time performance

·C allows precise control over execution time, which is critical for real-time embedded applications.

·Since Python is an interpreted language, it introduces garbage collection delays, making it unsuitable for real-time constraints.

Efficient memory usage

·C does not require a runtime interpreter, keeping memory usage to a minimum.

·The memory overhead of Python (due to dynamic typing and garbage collection) is not suitable for constrained devices.

d. Portability

·C code can run on bare-metal hardware or RTOS-based systems without modification.

·Python requires an interpreter, making it more difficult to port across microcontrollers.

04. Why Use C++ in Embedded Systems?

C++ builds on C by adding object-oriented programming (OOP) features while maintaining efficiency.

Code reusability and maintainability

·C++ supports classes, inheritance, and polymorphism, making code more modular.

·Example:

classLED {

private:

intpin;

public:

LED(intp) { pin = p; }

voidturnOn() { /* Code to turn on LED */}

voidturnOff() { /* Code to turn off LED */}

};

b. Abstraction without performance overhead

·C++ allows low-level control like C but adds abstraction (e.g., encapsulation).

·Embedded frameworks like Arduino and ROS (Robot Operating System) use C++ to leverage these advantages.

c. Support for embedded libraries

·The C++ Standard Template Library (STL) provides efficient data structures.

·Embedded frameworks like AUTOSAR use C++.

05. Why is Python Unsuitable for Embedded Systems?

a. High memory usage

·Python uses dynamic typing and garbage collection, leading to high RAM usage.

·Example:

x = 10 # Takes more memory than a C integer

b. Lack of real-time capabilities

·Python runs on an interpreter, making it slow and unpredictable for real-time tasks.

·Garbage collection (GC) can pause execution, which is unacceptable in safety-critical embedded systems.

c. Poor hardware access

·Python relies on external libraries (e.g., MicroPython) to interact with hardware.

·Native C/C++ code is faster for direct hardware control.

d. Requires Python runtime environment

·Python requires an interpreter or MicroPython, making it incompatible with many microcontrollers.

·C and C++ compile directly to machine code without an additional software layer.

06. When Should Python be Used in Embedded Systems?

While Python is not suitable for core embedded programming, it can be used for:

01. Prototyping and simulation:

·Python is excellent for rapid development and testing using Raspberry Pi, Jetson Nano, or BeagleBone.

02. Advanced control and AI integration:

·Python is well-suited for AI/ML applications in embedded systems, such as image processing.

03. IoT and data processing:

·Python can be used on edge devices for data analysis and communication with cloud servers.

Example:

import time

import RPi.GPIO as GPIO

GPIO.setmode(GPIO.BCM)

GPIO.setup(18, GPIO.OUT)

while True:

GPIO.output(18, GPIO.HIGH)

time.sleep(1)

GPIO.output(18, GPIO.LOW)

time.sleep(1)

07. Best Use Cases for C, C++, and Python

Use Case	Best Language
Real-time automotive systems (ABS, ECU, ADAS)	C
Low-power IoT sensors & microcontrollers	C
Embedded AI/ML applications	C++/Python
Robotics (ROS-based applications)	C++
Industrial automation & control systems	C
Rapid prototyping & simulations	Python

08. Conclusion: Why Choose C or C++ Instead of Python?

While Python is widely used for general programming, C and C++ remain the best choices for embedded systems for the following reasons:

• 1. Efficient memory usage (no garbage collection overhead)
• 2. Real-time execution (precise timing and direct hardware access)
• 3. Portability (runs on bare-metal hardware without an interpreter)
• 4. Power efficiency (critical for battery-powered devices)

• 5. Use C for low-level programming and real-time constraints.
• 6. Use C++ when object-oriented programming and abstraction are needed.
• 7. Use Python only for prototyping, IoT applications, or AI-based embedded systems.

Final recommendation: If you are working with embedded systems, C or C++ should be your top choice.

Follow us (for operational reference, please refer to the article: Send a message by following the public account), click the blue text at the top “Embedded Simulation Engineering” or long press to identify the QR code to follow