Can’t Define Variable Length Arrays in C? Don’t Be Ridiculous!

Hello everyone, I am Xiaokang. Today, let’s talk about a severely misunderstood feature of the C language—Variable Length Arrays!

Have you heard the saying “You can’t define variable length arrays in C”?

If you believed that, you have been seriously misled! Today, we will expose this widely spread “lie” and get to the bottom of it!

⚡ Friendly Reminder: Follow me to stay updated! There will be more hardcore technical articles shared later, guiding you through Linux C/C++ programming! 😆

1. First, what is a Variable Length Array?

In simple terms, a Variable Length Array (VLA) is an array whose size is not fixed and is determined at runtime.

Traditional C language arrays are defined like this:

int arr[10];  // Fixed size integer array of 10

This type of array has its size determined at compile time and cannot be changed once defined. But a variable length array is defined like this:

int n = 5;  // n can be a variable
int arr[n]; // Array size is determined by variable n

Looks simple, right? But many people believe that C language does not support this syntax!

2. Where did the “lie” come from?

This misunderstanding mainly arises from:

1. Early C standards (C89/C90) indeed did not support variable length arrays
2. Some compilers may not fully support them
3. People repeating what they hear; instructors or textbooks explaining C language may be outdated

Thus, the saying “C language cannot define variable length arrays” spread in the programming community…

3. The Truth: C99 Standard has supported Variable Length Arrays since 1999!

That’s right! Since the C99 standard in 1999, the C language has officially supported variable length arrays! It’s been over 20 years, how come your instructors haven’t updated their knowledge base? 😂

Let’s look at a simple example:

#include <stdio.h>

int main() {
    printf("Please enter the size of the array:");
    int size;
    scanf("%d", &size);
    
    // This is a variable length array! Size is determined by user input
    int numbers[size];
    
    printf("Please enter %d integers:\n", size);
    for(int i = 0; i < size; i++) {
        scanf("%d", &numbers[i]);
    }
    
    // Calculate average
    int sum = 0;
    for(int i = 0; i < size; i++) {
        sum += numbers[i];
    }
    
    printf("The average is: %.2f\n", (float)sum / size);
    
    return 0;
}

This code complies with the C99 standard, but remember, not all compilers support this feature! For example, the MSVC (Microsoft Visual C++) that comes with Visual Studio does not support variable length arrays.

4. What are the considerations for Variable Length Arrays?

Although variable length arrays are convenient, there are some limitations and considerations:

1. Can only be defined inside functions: Variable length arrays cannot be global or static variables

// Incorrect usage
int n = 10;
int global_arr[n];  // Compilation error!

// Correct usage
void func(int n) {
    int local_arr[n];  // This is allowed
}

2. Cannot be initialized: Cannot assign initial values directly when defining

int n = 5;
int arr[n] = {1, 2, 3, 4, 5};  // Compilation error!

3. Memory allocated on the stack: Variable length arrays allocate memory on the stack, and if the array is too large, it may lead to stack overflow

int n = 1000000;  // A very large number
int huge_arr[n];  // Dangerous! May cause stack overflow

4. Compatibility issues: The C++ standard does not support variable length arrays (although some C++ compilers support them as an extension)

5. How frequently are they used in practical applications?

To be honest, variable length arrays are not used particularly frequently in actual projects, mainly due to:

1. Memory safety considerations: Since they allocate memory on the stack, arrays of uncontrolled size may lead to stack overflow
2. Compatibility issues: Some embedded systems or older compilers may not support the C99 standard
3. Alternatives for dynamic memory allocation: For truly dynamic-sized arrays, many programmers prefer using <span>malloc</span>/<span>free</span>

// Alternative using malloc
int *arr = (int *)malloc(size * sizeof(int));
if(arr != NULL) {
    // Use arr
    free(arr);  // Remember to free memory after use
}

However, variable length arrays can still be very useful in the following scenarios:

1. Simple short-lived functions: When the array size is moderate and used only within the function
2. Teaching and learning: Understanding stack memory allocation mechanisms
3. Algorithm implementation: Some algorithms that require temporary arrays

6. How to choose? Variable Length Arrays vs Dynamic Memory Allocation

So, when should you use variable length arrays, and when should you use malloc? Here’s a simple guide:

• Use Variable Length Arrays: When the array size is moderate (within a few MB) and used only briefly within the current function
• Use malloc: When the array is large, needs to persist for a long time, or needs to be passed between functions

Conclusion: Don’t be deceived by the “lie” anymore!

The C language absolutely supports variable length arrays, which is an official feature of the C99 standard! Next time someone tells you it can’t be done, just retort, “Bro, your knowledge needs an update!”

So should I use Variable Length Arrays or not?

It’s like whether to eat spicy food—depends on the situation! 😄

For simple scenarios, you can use: Temporary small arrays? Variable length arrays are quick and convenient, and the code is clean.

For large projects, avoid using them: They can easily lead to stack overflow, have poor compatibility, and complicate debugging; some large companies even prohibit their use in coding standards.

In short: Understand it, use it moderately, and don’t misuse it. It’s like a “double-edged sword” in martial arts novels; it can be cool to use, but you need to be careful!

If you have any questions about the C language, feel free to leave a comment, and see you next time!

Oh, you made it this far?

Since you are interested in such “niche knowledge” as variable length arrays, we are likely of the same kind! 😎

「Follow Xiaokang to learn programming」 on WeChat for more insights?

There you will find: “Dehydrated essentials” of computer fundamentals, “Secret techniques” for Linux C/C++ development, and “Internal analysis” of major company interview questions…

My style has one characteristic:I explain programming like telling a story, making technology no longer dull.

Don’t forget to give a “like” and “follow”, and “share” with friends who need it~ Next time we will discuss something more exciting! 💻✨

How to follow my WeChat account?

Click on the WeChat account card below to follow.

Additionally, Xiaokang has created a technical discussion group, specifically for discussing technology and answering questions. If you encounter any difficulties while reading the article, feel free to ask in the group! I will do my best to help everyone, and there are many technical experts online to support us, so we can learn and grow together!